Coney Island Lighthouse Takes Step Toward Landmark Status
New York City's Landmarks Preservation Commission agreed on October 20 to consider the 1890 Coney Island Lighthouse as an individual landmark in Brooklyn, New York.
The Coney Island Lighthouse landmark process took its first step on Tuesday, October 20, 2026, when the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission agreed to list the lighthouse for consideration as an individual landmark. The lighthouse, built in 1890, stands at the western tip of the Coney Island peninsula in Brooklyn. It has guided boats through New York Harbor for more than 135 years and remains in operation today. That step does not yet make it a landmark, but it starts a formal process that could lead to protection.
The lighthouse is a 70-foot structure that was built when growing ferry traffic increased the need for navigational aids along the waterfront. It was automated in 1989, yet it continues to serve a navigational purpose for the U.S. Coast Guard. The keeper’s house beside it remains Coast Guard property, with the residence leased to the Sea Gate Association. The lighthouse is also linked to a notable keeper, widely recognised as the last civilian lighthouse keeper in Coast Guard service, adding to its historic interest.
Coney Island Lighthouse Landmark Process
Calendaring is only the first stage. A public hearing will follow, giving members of the public a chance to share views before the commission decides whether to designate the site. If designated, the lighthouse would gain legal protection, helping to preserve its structure and setting for future generations. Landmark status can also raise awareness of a place, encouraging people to learn about its history and its role in the harbour.
Access remains limited, even if landmark status is granted. The lighthouse sits inside Sea Gate, a private, gated residential community at the western end of Coney Island, so visitors cannot simply walk up to it. The official tour information page suggests contacting the U.S. Coast Guard or the Sea Gate Association to ask about a visit, though tours are not guaranteed. For now, the October 20 decision is a milestone, recognising a working lighthouse that has watched over New York Harbor since 1890.
Source: Secret NYC
